Two tough toys, two different jobs
The Goughnuts Ball and Tuffy Polly the Pig JR both fall under the Tuff Tested label, but they serve different play styles. The Goughnuts Ball is a solid rubber fetch toy built for powerful jaws and unpredictable bounce, while Polly the Pig JR is a plush toy with a rugged interior for smaller dogs who like to shake and snuggle. Neither is a universal replacement for the other; the right pick depends on your dog's size, chew intensity, and favorite games.
Below, we break down the catalog evidence for each toy so you can match one to your dog's habits without guessing.
Goughnuts Ball: built for fetch and power chewers
- Goughnuts Ball: 3 inches in diameter, ideal for interactive games of fetch, chase, and retrieval. This size suits medium to large dogs and makes the ball easy to spot and throw during outdoor play.

Goughnuts Ball - Goughnuts Ball: Made in the USA from advanced engineered rubber used in aerospace applications. The material is designed to withstand powerful jaws, making it a candidate for heavy chewers.
- Goughnuts Ball: Erratic bounce creates exciting, unpredictable fetch sessions. If your dog loves chasing unpredictable bounces, this ball keeps play engaging.
- Goughnuts Ball: Available in Green, Yellow, Orange, and Black Pro 50 toughness levels. You can choose a firmness that matches your dog's chew style, from most aggressive chewers to the toughest power chewers.
Tuffy Polly the Pig JR: a plush pal for smaller dogs
- Tuffy Dog Toys Polly the Pig JR: For dogs under 35 lb. This toy is sized for small to medium dogs, so it's not intended for larger breeds.

Tuffy Dog Toys Polly the Pig JR - Tuffy Dog Toys Polly the Pig JR: Made with three layers: soft fleece outside, plastic coating inside, and 1-2 layers of industrial grade luggage material. The layered construction adds durability for a plush toy, but it's still best for gentle play.
- Tuffy Dog Toys Polly the Pig JR: Size 10" x 5.5" x 3.5". The elongated shape is great for shaking and carrying, appealing to dogs who like to rag and toss.
Durability and play style at a glance
The Goughnuts Ball is a solid rubber toy designed for aggressive chewers, while Polly the Pig JR is a plush toy with reinforced layers for smaller dogs. Neither is indestructible, but they target different needs.
- Chew intensity: Goughnuts Ball: suitable for aggressive chewers and power chewers (Pro 50). Polly the Pig JR: better for light to moderate chewers due to its plush exterior.
- Play style: Goughnuts Ball: fetch, chase, and retrieval with an erratic bounce. Polly the Pig JR: shaking, carrying, and cuddling.
- Size suitability: Goughnuts Ball: 3-inch diameter suits medium to large dogs. Polly the Pig JR: for dogs under 35 lb.
- Material: Goughnuts Ball: advanced engineered rubber. Polly the Pig JR: fleece exterior, plastic coating, and luggage material layers.
Which toy fits your dog?
If your dog is a strong chewer who loves fetch and needs a toy that can handle serious jaw power, the Goughnuts Ball is the clear choice. Its solid rubber construction and toughness options (including Black Pro 50) make it a long-lasting option for heavy chewers.
If you have a smaller dog (under 35 lb) who enjoys plush toys but tends to destroy them quickly, Polly the Pig JR offers reinforced layers that may extend its life. It's not a chew toy for power chewers, but it's a good fit for gentle play and companionship.
Remember that no toy is indestructible. Always supervise play and remove damaged toys to keep your dog safe.



